HomeMy WebLinkAbout03082011 STORMWATER MANAGEMENTStorm WaterStorm Water
ManagementManagement
Program ReviewProgram Review
Briefing Overview
Storm Water Management (SWM) Program
•
Overview
Functional Components of SWM
•
Organizational Component of SWM
•
Requirements VS Resources
•
Recommendations
•
Council Discussion
•
2
Program OverviewProgram Overview
Functional ComponentsFunctional Components
Flood Control
•
Water Quality
•
Operations & Maintenance
•
3
Three Major ComponentsThree Major Components
Fully IntegratedFully Integrated
Flood Control
Water
Quality
Operations &
Maintenance
4
Resource Allocation Resource Allocation --$21,290,525$21,290,525
Flood Control9%$ 1,884,090
Water Quality13%$ 2,818,667
Operation and Maintenance58%$12,434,943
Debt Service
Debt Service10%$ 2,008,993
$2,008,993
Support Cost10%$ 2,143,832
Support Cost
$2,143,832
Operations &
10%
Maintenance
Water Quality
Operating Budget
CIP
10%
$9,839,863
$2,134,578
Water Quality
46%
10%
Operating Budget
$684,089
3%
3%
Flood Control
Operations &
Operating Budget
6%
Maintenance
12%
$684,090
CIP
Flood Control
$2,595,080
CIP
5
$1,200,000
CIP Distribution
FY 11 (Original Budget)$11,336,574
FY 12 (Proposed Budget)$ 5,929,658
Returned to General
SW Water Quality
Fund FY 11,
Projects,
$2,750,000, 24%
$2,134,578, 19%
Operations &
Propose Return to
Maintenance,
General Fund FY 12,
$2,595,080, 23%
Flood Control
$2,656,916, 23%
Projects,
$1,200,000, 11%
6
Flood ControlFlood Control
CIPCIP
Flood Control Projects Include:
Improving / Enhancing Existing Storm
•
Drain Pipes and Ditches
New Storm Drain Pipe Systems and
•
Roadway Culverts
New Storm Water Pump Stations
•
Expanded Storm Water Management
•
Systems (Ponds and BMP’s)
8
Recent Flood Control Recent Flood Control
AccomplishmentsAccomplishments
Brought to Construction
CIP 7-902North Beach Drainage$19,000,000
CIP 7-033Rosemont Forest –Phase II (Pump Sta.)$ 2,500,000
CIP 7-033Rosemont Forest –Phase IB () $ 400,000
Neighborhood
CIP 7-024Southern Canal Phase 1$ 300,000
CIP 7-183Lynnhaven Middle School BMP$ 200,000
Ready to Advertise
CIP 7-005North Lake Holly –Section II$ 5,200,000
CIP 7-016South Lake Holly –Section III$ 4,600,000
CIP 7-087Elizabeth River Shores$ 1,200,000
9
Flood Control -Program Drivers
•Provide necessary and feasible drainage Improvements
•Improvement of limited and inadequate drainage systems
that impact the street system and public and private property
•Addressing Longstanding Storm Water Backlog Projects
•Addressing Increased Citizen Expectation for Greater Storm
Drain Capacity within Older Neighborhoods (pre-1970’s)
10
FY 12 Flood Control CIP Projects
Project Expenditure Budget Summary Report grouped by: CIP Category, CIP Status
City of Virginia BeachFiscal Year 2012
CIPAppropriatedFY 2012FY 2013FY 2014FY 2015FY 2016FY 2017
ProjectTotalTo DateBudgetBudgetBudgetBudgetBudgetBudget
Proposed - Storm Water - Flood Control
7005000 North Lake Holly Watershed13,851,13513,551,135000300,00000
7010000 Elizabeth River Shores (Partial)2,130,4502,130,450000000
7016000 South Lake Holly Watershed7,758,0006,283,0000775,000500,000200,00000
7024000 Southern Canal/Lead Ditch and Culvert 950,000950,000000000
7033000 Rosemont Forest Drainage Improvements6,800,0006,800,000000000
7035000 Lawson Forest Drainage1,080,000630,000450,00000000
7036000 Baker Road Culvert & Ditch 450,000270,000180,00000000
Improvements
7037000 Bellamy Manor Outfall Ditch450,000450,000000000
7038000 Thoroughgood Drainage - Interim670,00095,000200,000175,000200,000000
7039000 Level Green - Interim675,0000000225,000450,0000
7040000 Aragona Village-Interim650,0000000225,000425,0000
7049000 Beach Garden Park - Kilborne Ct & Holly 900,000900,000000000
Rd
7063000 Neighborhood Storm Water Infrastructure 9,159,8868,851,82050,00050,00050,00050,00058,06650,000
7151000 Cape Henry Beach Drainage883,066000000883,066
7902000 North Beach Drainage29,142,52329,142,523000000
SWU05 Shore Drive Drainage Preliminary Design320,0000320,00000000
Proposed
75,870,06070,053,9281,200,0001,000,000750,0001,000,000933,066933,066
GovMax V5 12/28/2010
11
FY 11
Reduction
Impacts of FY11 Overall
Fund Reduction of
2.75M/Year
Total
Proj.ProjectYear 1Year 2Year 3Year 4Year 5Year 6Project
No.NameFY 10-11FY 11-12FY 12-13FY 13-14FY 14-15FY 15-16Impact
7.005North Lake Holly Watershed
$1,491,000$0$500,000$300,000$500,000$500,000$3,291,000
7.016South Lake Holly Watershed
$759,000$2,580,000$2,000,000$950,000$0$0$6,289,000
Cape Henry Beach Drainage
7.151
$500,000$170,000$250,000$1,500,000$2,250,000$2,250,000$6,920,000
(Partial)
$2,750,000$2,750,000$2,750,000$2,750,000$2,750,000$2,750,000
12
7-005 North Lake Holly
Legend
Completed
Section I-A$ 1.43 M
Section I-B$ 2.47 M
Programmed
Section II$ 5.29 M
Section IV$ 2.08 M
Section I-C$2.01 M
Not Fully Funded
Section III $ 3.79 M
Total-Funding to Date= Not Fully Funded
$17.07M -$13.85 M=$3.22 M
13
7-016 South Lake Holly
Legend
Programmed
Section III$ 2.3 M
Section II$ 3.91 M
Section I$ 0.60 M
Not Funded
Section
Section IV$ 5.93 M
III
Total-Funding to Date= Not Fully Funded
14
$12.74 M -$7.76 M=$4.98 M
7-151 Cape Henry Beach (Partial)
•$6.9 M -Full Funding of Design and
Partial Funding of Construction
•$30 to $50 M –Total Project Cost
Great Neck Rd.
15
Flood Control BacklogFlood Control Backlog
7-005North Lake Holly Watershed$ 3,291,000
7-016South Lake Holly Watershed$ 5,000,000
7-151Cape Henry Drainage$50,000,000
7-090Eastern Park Drainage Improvement$ 4,350,000
7-089College Park/Level Green Drainage $ 5,650,000
Improvements
7-087Aragona Village$ 6,100,000
7-088Bay Colony$ 1,200,000
Total$76 M
FY 12 –FY 17Total Funding$ 5,816,132
16
Water QualityWater Quality
Water Quality Requirements
Storm water discharge through the City
storm drainage system is regulated.
18
Water Quality Requirements
The City is held accountable for the health of
our bays, rivers and creeks.
19
Recent Water Quality Recent Water Quality
AccomplishmentsAccomplishments
•Negotiated New TMDL Implementation Plans
•Composting Facility
•Improved Microbial Testing Methodologies
•Corps of Engineers Lynnhaven Study
•No Discharge Zone –Lynnhaven River
Alanton Elementary School
BMP
•Watershed Assessments For Construction
Lynnhaven Middle
School BMP
20
Water Quality Program DriversWater Quality Program Drivers
•Federal Clean Water Act
•State Storm Water
Regulations
•Virginia Beach Citizens’
Expectations
•Environmental Committees
and Organizations
21
Total Maximum Daily Loads Total Maximum Daily Loads
(TMDL’s)(TMDL’s)
•Maximum Pollutant Load that a Water Body can
receive and still Meet its Designated Use.
•Sets Allowable Pollutant Loads for our Lakes,
Rivers, Bays and Creeks
•Enforced via VPDES Storm Water
Permit Regulations
22
Storm Water FY 12Storm Water FY 12
QualityQuality
Program Review Program Review ––Water Water
How Serious Is EPA?
EPA Enforcement Actions on Localities
•Dallas, Texas -$5M in Fines and Consent Orders
•8 Small Localities In Massachusetts -$218,000 in
Direct Costs and Fines, Plus Consent Orders
•79 Localities in Pennsylvania, Consent Orders
Only. Costs Unknown.
•3 Maryland Localities (Including Baltimore)
$250,000 in Direct Costs and Fines, Plus
Consent Orders
23
FY 12 Water Quality CIP Request
Project Expenditure Budget Summary Report grouped by: CIP Category, CIP Status
City of Virginia BeachFiscal Year 2012
CIPAppropriatedFY 2012FY 2013FY 2014FY 2015FY 2016FY 2017
ProjectTotalTo DateBudgetBudgetBudgetBudgetBudgetBudget
Storm Water Quality
Proposed
7027000 SWM Master Planning, Analysis, and Inventory1,895,906995,906150,000150,000150,000150,000150,000150,000
7153000 Lynnhaven Watershed Restoration5,014,1683,191,532300,000300,000300,000304,500309,068309,068
7159000 Water Quality Participation Projects1,501,500901,500100,000100,000100,000100,000100,000100,000
7183000 Storm Water Quality Enhancements13,182,8136,822,1131,184,5781,384,5781,107,578853,078915,444915,444
SWU06 Southern River TMDL Implementation Plan1,200,0000200,000200,000200,000200,000200,000200,000
SWU07 Elizabeth River TMDL Implementation Plan1,200,0000200,000200,000200,000200,000200,000200,000
Proposed
23,994,38711,911,0512,134,5782,334,5782,057,5781,807,5781,874,5121,874,512
GovMax V5 12/28/2010
24
Impacts of Proposed FY12 Impacts of Proposed FY12
Overall Fund Reduction of Overall Fund Reduction of
$656,916 /Year$656,916 /Year
Part of Proposed
FY 12 Reduction
Total
Proj.ProjectYear 1Year 2Year 3Year 4Year 5Year 6Project
No.NameFY 10-11FY 11-12FY 12-13FY 13-14FY 14-15FY 15-16Impact
Storm Water Quality
7.183Enhancements$656,916$656,916$656,916$656,916$656,916$656,916$3,941,496
$656,916$656,916$656,916$656,916$656,916$656,916
25
7-183 Storm Water Quality
Sub-Basin Retrofits
$0.66 M
Comprehensive Stormwater Quality Improvement Program, CIP 7-183
Year 1Year 2Year 3Year 4Year 5
Thalia Creek - WS 04:
Study for Water
Quality is $225 K; No
Water Quantity Rudee/Owl Creek - West Neck Creek -
Study
Mill Dam Creek - WS 30B: Study yet due to WS 29: Study for WS 10: Study for Portion of Elizabeth River
Study for Water Quality Ches Bay Regs-this Water Quality and Water Quality and Watershed: Study for Water
and Water Quantity is estimate is $400K for Water Quantity is Water Quantity is Quality and Water Quantity
$210KStudy$200K$200K - $300Kis $400K - $500K
Mill Dam Creek - WS Thalia Creek - WS Rudee/Owl Creek -
Design
30B: Design is $150-04: Design is $250-WS 29: Design is West Neck Creek - WS 10:
$250K$350K$250K - $350KDesign is $300K to $400K
Mill Dam Creek -
WS 30B: Thalia Creek - WS 04:
Construction
Construction is $600-Construction is Rudee/Owl Creek - WS 29:
$750K$750K - $850KConstruction is $900K - $1.1M
26
Impact to 7-183 Storm Water
Quality Sub-Basin Retrofits
$0.66 M
FY 09 - 10FY 10 - 11FY 11 - 12FY 12 - 13FY 13 - 14FY 14 - 15FY 15 - 16
Thalia Creek - WS 04:
Study for Water
Quality is $225 K; No
Mill Dam Creek - Water Quantity Rudee/Owl Creek -
Study
WS 30B: Study Study yet due to WS 29: Study for
for Water Quality Ches Bay Regs-this Water Quality and
and Water estimate is $400K for Water Quantity is
Quantity is $210KStudy$200K
Mill Dam Creek - WS Thalia Creek -
Design
30B: Design is $150-WS 04: Design
$250K is $250-$350K
Thalia Creek -
Mill Dam Creek - WS 30B:
WS 04:
Construction
Construction is $600-$750K
Construction is
$750K - $850K
27
Water Quality Backlog Water Quality Backlog
7-183Storm Water Quality Enhancements$ 3,941,496
NewRudee / Owl Creek TMDL$ 1,200,000
NewVirginia Storm Water Permit Requirements $ 3,000,000
Total$ 8 M
28
Operations and Operations and
MaintenanceMaintenance
Storm Water Storm Water
OperationsOperations
Funding Overview
•
Accomplishments & Requirements
•
Resourcing / Backlog
•
30
Operations FY 12 BudgetOperations FY 12 Budget
Lake
BMP Inspection
Pump Stations
Maintenance
Street Sweeping
4%
•Storm Water Pipe System
4%
1%
2%
Storm Response
4%
•Off Road Ditches & Canals
Dams, Spillways,
•Roadside Ditches
Weirs
5%
•Street Sweeping
Roadside
Ditches
16%
•Dams, Spillways, Weirs
•Pump Stations
•BMP Inspection
Off Road Ditches
& Canals
Stormwater Pipe
17%
System
•Lake Maintenance
47%
Funding $12,434,943
31
Projected ReductionProjected Reduction
CIP 7-004, Neighborhood Infra. Rehab.($1.75M)
CIP 7-152, Lake Management($0.25M)
(Ponds/Canal Dredging)
Part of Proposed
FY 12 Annual Reduction
32
Neighborhood Infrastructure Neighborhood Infrastructure
RehabilitationRehabilitation
CIP 7CIP 7--004004
•Work assessed based on
cave in history
•Prioritized by subdivision
Top 8 Neighborhoods:
Including construction and population
•Heavy Rehabilitation
statistics
•Top 18 identified
Princess Anne Plaza1960s / 11,000
Aragona1950s / 9,000
neighborhoods $36.5M
Green Run1970s / 19,000
Glenwood1980s / 10,000
•FY-11 $3,238,800
Ocean Lakes1980s / 7,000
Kings Grant 1960s / 9,000
Windsor Woods1960s / 5,000
•FY-12 funding $1,488,800
Indian Lakes 1970s / 8,000
•Reduced to 1 every other
33
year in 6 year schedule
Infrastructure RehabilitationInfrastructure Rehabilitation
CIP 7CIP 7--004004
NEIGHBORHOODEST. / POPULATIONCOST
•Princess Anne Plaza 1960’s/ 11,000$5.5M
•Aragona1950’s / 9,000$2M
•Green Run1970’s / 19,000$4M
•Glenwood1980’s / 10,000$2M
•Ocean Lakes1980’s / 7,000$2M
•Kings Grant 1960’s / 9,000$2M
•Windsor Woods1960’s / 5,000$2M
•Indian Lakes 1970’s / 8,000$2M
•Salem Woods1980’s / 6,000$2M
•Fairfield 1970’s/ 6,000$2M
•Salem Lakes 1980’s/ 10,000$1M
•Red Mill Farms 1980’s/ 19,000$2M
•Lagomar 1980’s/ 4,000$1M
•Magic Hollow 1970’s/ 10,000$2M
•Malibu 1960’s/ 5,000$1M
•Southgate 1980’s/ 3,000$1M
•Foxfire 1990’s/ 5,000$1M
•Courthouse Estates 1990’s/ 8,000$2M
$ 36.5M
34
Infrastructure RehabilitationInfrastructure Rehabilitation
CIP 7CIP 7--004004
•2200 miles of pipe
Cycle Annual
Miles/ Yr
(Yrs)Cost
•FY 12 funding $1.49M
5044$16.3M
•Current cycle –550 years
6037$13.7 M
7032$11.8 M
•Rehabilitation cycle goal
8028$10.3 M
–Design life -50 years
9025$9.2 M
–Target -100 years
10022$8.1 M
–Requirement $8.1M
15015$5.8 M
5504$1.5 M
35
Pipe/Structure Cave In Pipe/Structure Cave In
Repair BacklogRepair Backlog
•Cave In Repair Backlog (current 894)
•In House Crew Capability Service
FYBacklog
Requests
–About 700 Cave Ins per year
05-06
98615
Total of 4 crews
o
06-07
954215
leaves increasing backlog
o
07-08
856140
•Annual req’t= 1200 repairs
08-09
839219
•Additional Crew
09-10
1213728
–Perform additional 175 cave ins
–Annual Cost -$850,000 (6 FTE + equip)
•$3.0M/yr in six year program eliminates backlog
36
Off Road and Roadside DitchingOff Road and Roadside Ditching
Off Road Ditches total about 237 Miles
Roadside Ditches total 448 miles
Canals total over 25 miles
Goal is a cycle time of 8 Years or about
25 miles per year.
Degree of difficulty and emergency
failure repairs limited production to 8
miles in 2010
Sheriff’s Workforce Augmentation
37
Off Road Ditch MaintenanceOff Road Ditch Maintenance
•Goal: 8 year cycle time, about 25 miles
•Current cycle 30 years
•Current in-house capability: 6 mi/year
•Additional crew
–8-9 mi/year
–Friday –Monday shift
Leverage sheriff’s work force
o
Annual Cost -$850,000
o
(6 FTE + equip))
o
Heavy vegetation/clearing
o
Viking Road Ditch
38
Street SweepingStreet Sweeping
Locations and Watershed Areas
•Residential Sweeping (Lynnhaven Watershed)
–Average 18 month cycle
•Arterial Sweeping (major roadways)
–Average 60-90 days cycle
•Oceanfront Sweeping
–7 nights per week, May to September
•Town Center Sweeping
–One night per week
Collected/Removed
Resources
10,000 CY of Sediment
•5 Mechanical Sweepers
•1 Vacuum Sweeper
•Staff:
–4 FTEs -Motor Equipment Operator III
–0.5 FTE –Maintenance Supervisor
39
Dams and SpillwaysDams and Spillways
Inventory: 38 dams/spillways
Condition Assessed on a 1 to 3
year cycle dependant upon
condition
MS4 Reporting requirement
FY-10 Reconstruction of Lake
James Spillway
FY-11 Kingston Dam and
Spillway Major Reconstruction
40
Storm Water Pump StationsStorm Water Pump Stations
Total Pump Station Inventory is 21
Monthly Preventative Maintenance
Operational Testing, Start-ups
Incidental Minor Repairs
Current funding levels insufficient for
41
major rehabilitation and repairs
Storm Water Pump StationStorm Water Pump Station
Maintenance & RepairMaintenance & Repair
SWUSWU--0909
Project should include upgrades, rehabilitation, repairs and replacement of existing
storm water pump stations.
•Maintain aging infrastructure to protect $100M investment
•Improve stations experiencing hydraulic and mechanical problems
•Maintain 21 pump stations
•Currently not funded
•Requirement -$500 K / Year
42
42
Hurricane Protection Hurricane Protection
Infrastructure MaintenanceInfrastructure Maintenance
SWUSWU--0808
Project should include inspection, design, rehabilitation & repairs to the
hurricane protection infrastructure
•All associated ocean outfalls
•All seawall cap and associated storm water trunk line
•Current maintenance & repair funded through highway operating accounts
•Requirement -$250 K / Year
43
BMP MaintenanceBMP Maintenance
•Water Quality Treatment
BMP2010 Inventory
BMPs
of Public and
Type
Private
–Inventory captured in
Work Management
Infiltration451
System
Ponds/Lakes1379
–Inspection Cycle by Type
–Maintenance &
Filtration30
Enforcement
Outlet Control21
Other*200
Totals2083
727 Wet Ponds727 Wet Ponds
•Other includes Vortechnics/Stormceptor/etc.
& 652 Dry & 652 Dry
and other undefined types
PondsPonds
44
Lake Management CIP 7Lake Management CIP 7--152152
Ponds/Canal DredgingPonds/Canal Dredging
•Significant Growth in Inventory
•Age Related Backlog
678 Wet Ponds < 10 ft Deep678 Wet Ponds < 10 ft Deep
••
Wet Pond Inventory Growth Rate
Private: 248Private: 248
••
Schools: 11Schools: 11
••
CVB Owned: 93*CVB Owned: 93*
••
727
Private But City Maintained: 326*Private But City Maintained: 326*
••
637
571
*SW Utility Responsibility = 419*SW Utility Responsibility = 419
412
Current Current
315
288
254
BacklogBacklog
(reflects 105 ponds)(reflects 105 ponds)
$84 MILLION $84 MILLION
45
Lake Management CIP 7Lake Management CIP 7--152152
Ponds/Canal DredgingPonds/Canal Dredging
•Inspection & Maintenance Required by Permit
•Predominant Maintenance Cost =
Cycle Annual
Lakes / Yr
(Yrs)Cost
2021$17 M
SW Utility 20 Year Maintenance PlanSW Utility 20 Year Maintenance Plan
••Total Ponds: Total Ponds: 419419
3014$11 M
••Annual Rate: Annual Rate: 21 Ponds/Year21 Ponds/Year
4010.5$8.4 M
Annual Dredge Cost $17 M/YearAnnual Dredge Cost $17 M/Year
••
508.4$6.7 M
1004.2$3.4 M
2002.1$1.7 M
••Currently Operating at Currently Operating at
3001.5$1.1 M
950 Year Cycle Time 950 Year Cycle Time
4001.0$883 K
••Target: 100 Year Cycle timeTarget: 100 Year Cycle time
5000.8$670 K
46
9500.4$353 K
Lake Management CIP 7Lake Management CIP 7--152152
Ponds/Canal DredgingPonds/Canal Dredging
Completion Proposed
LakeCost
DateDate
Kingston20112011$400K
Brigadoon Lake 220142012$1.0 M
Brigadoon Lake 320152012$500 K
Brigadoon Lake 420152012$250 K
Brigadoon Lake 520162012$200 K
Brigadoon Lake 620162012$300 K
Green Run Lake 120182013$1.5 M
Green Run Lake 220202013$1.5 M
Green Run Lake 320202014$1.0 M
Green Run Lake 420222014$750 K
Green Run Lake 520232014$500 K
Brookside Lake20242014$500 K
West LakePembroke20342018$6.0 M
StratfordChase 120342019$250 K
Stratford Chase220352019$500 K
Stratford Chase 320352019$150 K
Level Green Lake 120362019$500 K
Level Green Lake 220372019$250 K
ReedtownLake(Wishart)20382019$750 K
Rock Creek 120392020$250 K
47
Operations FY 12 BudgetOperations FY 12 Budget
Lake
BMP Inspection
Pump Stations
Maintenance
Street Sweeping
4%
•Storm Water Pipe System
4%
1%
2%
Storm Response
4%
•Off Road Ditches & Canals
Dams, Spillways,
•Roadside Ditches
Weirs
5%
•Street Sweeping
Roadside
Ditches
16%
•Dams, Spillways, Weirs
•Pump Stations
•BMP Inspection
Off Road Ditches
& Canals
Stormwater Pipe
17%
System
•Lake Maintenance
47%
Funding $12,434,943
48
Operations BacklogOperations Backlog
•Lake Maintenance CIP 7-152 $84.0M
•Storm Water Infrastructure Rehab CIP 7-004$37.0M
•Pipe/Structure (Cave In) $18.0M
•Off Road Ditch $10.2M
•Hurricane Protection Infrastructure Maintenance$ 1.5M
•Storm Water Pump Station Maintenance & Repair$ 3.0M
$153.7 M
49
Combined Storm Water BacklogCombined Storm Water Backlog
7.005North Lake Holly Watershed$ 3,291,000
7.016South Lake Holly Watershed$ 5,000,000
7-151Cape Henry Drainage$50,000,000
7-090Eastern Park Drainage Improvement$ 4,350,000
7-089College Park/Level Green Drainage Imp.$ 5,650,000
7-087Aragona Village$ 6,100,000
7-088Bay Colony$ 1,200,000
7.183Storm Water Quality Enhancements$ 3,941,496
NewRudee / Owl Creek TMDL$ 1,200,000
NewVirginia Storm Water Permit Requirements$ 3,000,000
7-152Lake Mgmt $84,000,000
7-004Storm Water Infrastructure Rehab $37,000,000
Pipe/Structure Cave In Repair$18,000,000
Off Road Ditch Maintenance$ 10,200,000
SWU-08 Hurricane Protection Maintenance$ 1,500,000
SWU-09Storm Water Pump Station Maint. & Repair$ 3,000,000
Total$237.5 M
50
Resource Allocation Resource Allocation --$21,290,525$21,290,525
Flood Control9%$ 1,884,090
Water Quality13%$ 2,818,667
Operation and Maintenance58%$12,434,943
Debt Service10%$ 2,008,993
Debt Service
Support Cost10%$ 2,143,832
$2,008,993
Support Cost
Operations &
$2,143,832
Maintenance
10%
Operating
Storm Water
Water Quality
Budget
CIP
CIP
10%
$9,839,863
FY 11
$2,134,578
Water
CUT
Quality
$2.7M
46%
$2.1M
Water Quality
24%
10%
19%
Operating
Budget
3%
$684,089
3%
Flood Control
6%
Ops +
12%
FY 12,
Operating
Maint,
Flood
CUT
Flood Control
$2.6M
Budget
Operations &
Control
$2.7M
23%
CIP
$684,090
Maintenance
$1.2M
23%
$1,200,000
CIP
11%
51
$2,595,080
20% cut to the entire program
48% cut to the CIP
Resourcing The BacklogResourcing The Backlog
Elimination is Not Affordable
1¢ on the SW Fee = $885,000
?
$237M ·$885K = 267¢
?
10 year program to address the backlog requires a 27¢ fee
?
increase (more than doubles the current SW fee)
Reducing the Growth of the Backlog is Imperative
52
FY12-FY14 Storm Water Requirements / Resourcing
Funding
Project/Program
CostRequiredFY12FY13FY14Notes
$3.22M
$17M.5
¢
Restores FY11 cut /Debt Serviced
North Lake Holly
(CIP 7-005)
$12.7M$4.98M.8
¢
Restores FY11 cut /Debt Serviced
South Lake Holly
(CIP 7-016)
$50M$6.9M1.01.5
¢¢
Restores FY11 cut / Debt Serviced
Cape Henry Beach Drainage
(CIP 7-151)
$1.7M$.85M.9.9
¢¢
Increases response to citizen requests
Stand-up Off-RoadDitch Crew
weekend crew with Sheriff’s Workforce
$3M$.8M.9
¢
Increases response to citizen requests for
Stand-upPipe Structure Crew
infrastructure restoration
(Cave-in)
$84M$3.25M2.01.01.0
¢¢¢
Restores FY12 cut / Initiates a 100 year
Lake Management
(CIP 7-152)
Maintenance Cycle
(pond/lake/canaldredging)
Begins to address Chesapeake TMDL
$37M$7.25M1.551.351.55
¢¢
Prevents FY12 cut / Initiates an 80 year
Neighborhood Infrastructure
Maintenance Cycle
Rehabilitation
(CIP 7-004)
Partial Debt Serviced
Prevents FY12 cut
$8M$657K.35.55.95
¢¢¢
StormwaterEnhancements
Begins to address Chesapeake TMDL
Sub-basin retrofits
(CIP 7-183)
Initiates a Maintenance, Repair and
$3.0M$500K.30.2
¢¢
Stormwater Pump Maintenance
Replace Program
& Repair
(SWU-09)
Initiates a Monitoring, Maintenance and
$1.5M$250K.2
¢
Beach Erosion Control &
Repair Program
Hurricane Protection
(SWU-09)
53
TOTAL
7.555
¢¢¢
Storm Water Fee per ERUStorm Water Fee per ERU
ERU = the impervious area of a residence
FY11FY 12 FY 13 FY 14
7.5¢5¢5¢
Daily$0.241$0.316$0.366$0.416
Monthly$7.23$9.48$10.98$12.48
60Days$14.46$18.96$21.96$24.96
Annual$87.96$115.34$133.59$151.84
The 7.5¢ in FY12 provides only $1.2M additional Storm Water Funds
54
after offsetting the FY11 and FY12 General Fund contribution cuts.
Relegated to Crisis Management Relegated to Crisis Management
w/o Enhanced Fundingw/o Enhanced Funding
Completes the top 2 &
•Flood Control Projects: $76M
begins #3
•Water Quality Projects: $8M
Addresses 1/3
•Operations & Maintenance
Gets us to 1
–Neighborhood Infrastructure: $36.5M
neighborhood/year
–Cave Ins: $18M
Counters growth of backlog –adds another crew
–Ditch Maintenance: $10M
Adds two crews–reduces backlog
improves maint cycle from 20 yrs to 10
–Street Sweeping: TBD in FY13
Addresses top 20
–Pond/Lake/Channel Maintenance: $84M
in 8 years
Implements a 100 yr maint cycle
–Pump Maintenance: $3M
Protects $100M investment
–Hurricane Protection Maintenance: $1.5M
Returns road
55
maint funds
Council DiscussionCouncil Discussion
FY12FY12--FY14 Storm Water FY14 Storm Water
Requirements/ResourcingRequirements/Resourcing
Funding
Project/ProgramCostRequiredFY12FY13FY14Notes
North Lake Holly $17M$3.22M.5Restores FY11 cut
¢
(CIP 7-005)
Debt Serviced
South Lake Holly $12.7M$4.98M.8Restores FY11 cut
¢
(CIP 7-016)
Debt Serviced
Cape Henry Beach Drainage $50M$6.9M1.01.5Restores FY11 cut
¢¢
(CIP 7-151)
Debt Serviced
Stand-up Off-Road Ditch Crew $1.7M$.85M.9.9Increases response to citizen requests
¢¢
weekend crew with Sheriff's Workforce
Stand–up Pipe Structure (Cave-in) Crew $3M$.8M.9Increases response to citizen requests for
¢
infrastructure restoration
Lake Management$84M$3.25M2.01.01.0Restores FY12 cut
¢¢¢
(pond/lake/canal dredging) Initiates a 100 year Maintenance Cycle
(CIP 7-152)
Begins to address Chesapeake TMDL
Neighborhood Infrastructure$37M$7.25M1.551.351.55Prevents FY12 cut
¢¢
Rehabilitation Initiates an 80 year Maintenance Cycle
(CIP 7-004)
Partial Debt Serviced
Stormwater Enhancements $14M$657K.35.55.95Prevents FY12 cut
¢¢¢
Sub-basin Retrofits Begins to address Chesapeake TMDL
(CIP 7-183)
Stormwater Pump Maintenance and Repair $3.0M$500K.30.2Initiates a Maintenance, Repair and
¢¢
(SWU-09)
Replace Program
Beach Erosion Control & Hurricane $1.5M$250K.2Initiates a Monitoring, Maintenance and
¢
Protection Maintenance Repair Program
(SWU-08)
57
TOTAL
7.555
¢¢¢
Storm Water Storm Water FY FY 20122012
Revenue Generation PotentialRevenue Generation Potential
FY 12 = 241,549 ERU’sFY 12 = 241,549 ERU’s
AnnualERU
Daily RateAnnualIncreaseOver 6 Years
Rate
$0.01/ Day Increase$0.251$91.61$881,654$5,289,924
$0.02/ Day Increase$0.261$95.26$1,763,307$10,579,842
$0.03/ Day Increase$0.271$98.91$2,644,961$15,869,766
$0.05/ Day Increase$0.291$106.21$4,408,269$26,449,614
$0.075 /Day Increase$0.316$115.34$6,612,404$39,674,424
58
Current Fund SummaryCurrent Fund Summary
SWU Generate $21,058,267 Annually
•
ERU’s (FY 11) = 239,394
•
ERU Annual Fee = $87.965
•
ERU Daily Fee= $ 0.241
•
59
Storm Water Fee per ERUStorm Water Fee per ERU
FY08FY 09FY 10FY 11
Daily$0.181$0.201$0.221$0.241
Monthly$5.43$6.03$6.63$7.23
60Days$10.86$12.06$13.26$14.46
Annual$66.06$73.36$80.66$87.96
60