Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutSEPTEMBER 26, 2023 FORMAL SESSION C's titer CrIt?i, 4*t"'''‘..::.:;(ZS ofi OUR VIRGINIA BEACH CITY COUNCIL Virginia Beach, Virginia September 26, 2023 Mayor Robert M. Dyer called to order the FORMAL SESSION in the City Council Conference Room, Tuesday, September 26, 2023, at 2:30 P.M Council Members Present: Mayor Robert M. Dyer, Barbara M. Henley, N. D. "Rocky"Holcomb, Dr.Amelia N. Ross-Hammond, Jennifer Rouse, Joashua F. "Joash"Schulman, Chris Taylor, Vice Mayor Rosemary Wilson and Sabrina D. Wooten Council Members Absent: Robert W. "Worth"Remick—Ill Michael F. Berlucchi—Arrived at 4:10 P.M 2 ADD ON • ITEM#74747 • 2:31 P.M. City Manager Duhaney advised Brent McKenzie, Assistant to the City Manager — Legislative Affairs Director, would like a few minutes to provide the requirements to change the e City's Charter and request the Body's direction going forward. Mayor Dyer welcomed Mr. McKenzie. Mr.McKenzie expressed his appreciation to City Council for their continued support and advised pursuant to the Code of Virginia, a request by the City`Council to the General Assembly to amend the City Charter requires either a.public hearing or a referendum. Mr.McKenzie advised he anticipates the following three (3)changes to the Charter;Implementing the 10-1 Election System, Change to the City Council process for filling Council Member vacancies and adding a fifth member and an alternate member to the City's Board of Equalization. Mr.McKenzie advised if the Body would like to hold a Public Hearing, an advertisement is required to be placed seven (7)days in advance. Mr. McKenzie requested the Body's direction. By consensus, Mayor Dyer directed Mr. McKenzie to coordinate with staff to make'the appropriate arrangements for_the Public Hearing. September 26, 2023 3 CITY COUNCIL'S BRIEFINGS HOUSING AFFORDABILITY STUDY UPDATE ITEM#74748 2:33 P.M. Mayor Dyer welcomed Ruth Hill, Director —Housing and Neighborhood Preservation, Mel Jones, Co- Director and Research Scientist Virginia Center for Housing Research at Virginia Tech and Jonathan Knopf Executive Director for Programs — Housing Forward Virginia. Mr. Knopf expressed his appreciation to City Council for their continued support: Virginia Beach Housing Study Preliminary Housing Solutions Policy Framework HousingForward Virginia VCHR September 26.2023 bnathan Knopf Mel bnes Eric Mel Seungbee Choi Mark Goldberg-Foes 11el �i VCHRV Here are Today's goals: Today's goals I. Review study update process and next steps 2. Discuss policy framework 3. Move toward consensus on selected solutions September 26, 2023 4 CITY COUNCIL'S BRIEFINGS HOUSING AFFORDABILITY STUDY UPDATE ITEM#74748 (Continued) Here is a glimpse of what has been completed and what is planned: What's already done,and what's next? d•i.re•ua. ::.;::.6�. :2.:V •. . Ovarteed Ibunel :yrWuitpr, : U. UMW*inter slows. Yt�nd!•as.a :fr rowgk Must Focus sr•�c• xIGyMtf. a..al as and Oan How we'll build solutions Organized into polity Each solution will include: framework(next slide) • Plain-language summary • Detailed technical description Focus on qualityover • Implementation steps and timeline quantity • Roles and responsibilities • Funding sources and opportunities • Benchmarks and metrics for success • Relevant examples and best practices September 26, 2023 5 CITY COUNCIL'S BRIEFINGS HOUSING AFFORDABILITY STUDY UPDATE ITEM#74748 (Continued) The next few slides provide the Policy framework details: Policy fra m ework rategtit priced lesStrategic priorities • Foamed activities that require more effort but have the biggest payoff a • Build long-term capacity to address housing needs • Provide opportunity for City to innovate and lead among peers Complexity • Policy framework Fay win. Easy wins • Simple tasks with less work,but still High impact result in meaningful progress Low complexity • Fewer decision points,but funding or policy choices may be tough • Build on clear,proven examples of success • Take advantage of existing infrastructure without much need for Complexity - additional capacity September 26, 2023 6 CITY COUNCIL'S BRIEFINGS HOUSING AFFORDABILITY STUDY UPDATE ITEM#74748 (Continued) Policy framework 1 B.ck grountl work Easy wins Strategic Fealties Activities that require additional Hlgh'mpect homework but can likely be ;.nptrmry Hrglr complexity completed within current or future s2. planning efforts E Background work • Long-term objectives lu migrate day- today City operations to support its Low impact housing goals Low complexity Complexity Policy fram ework " Thankless tasks Snlegkprlarnles • Not advisable Mgt)impact Y .;^S malty HO complexity • Reuse or abandon tasks In thefuture r. if they begin to meet this criteria E e Thankless tasks Low impact High complexity .... .-. - — Complexii September 26, 2023 7 CITY COUNCIL'S BRIEFINGS HOUSING AFFORDABILITY STUDY UPDATE ITEM#74748 (Continued) Here are the action items derived from the Policy framework: Strategic priorities Easy wins Background work 1.Develop•City-managed 1.Create a Housing Assistance 1.Pursue innovative self-sustaining Housing Trust Fund Fund for workers mixed-noome,mixed-use rental 2.Use Virginia Beach 2.Leverage Virginia Statewide development options Development Authority to Community tend Trust to 2.Research opportunities to fund new large-sole mixed- create permanent affordable simplify and streamline the use development protects homeownership opportunities permitting and review processes 3.Design and incorporate a 3.Consider an affordable housing housing education campaign advisory board to guide the into successful community development of new zoning engagement efforts ordinance changes and the Workforce Housing Program The next several slides provide strategic priorities: Strategic priority Rl Develop a City- Begin planning effort to determine: managed Housing 1, Where the funding will come from Trust Fund 2. How the fund will be governed end operated 3. What needs will be prioritized Full solution will provide detailed guidance and recommendations for that process.based on: • Initial Council and staff input(and guardrails) • High-priority housing needs from date • Lessons from other HIPS In Virginia e Relevant best practices from HTFs beyond Virginia September 26, 2023 8 CITY COUNCIL'S BRIEFINGS HOUSING AFFORDABILITY STUDY UPDATE ITEM#74748 (Continued) HTFexam pies in Virginia a.hmandAfferd.ble Misrlottendlle Affordable klinpan Affordable Alexandra Housing Homing Toad Fund Housing Fund Havana investment Fund Opportunities Fund Merdtlle Heuunp hud Morandria Housing Re'd04rlbma00d Moudnp Advisory Committee Multiple oversight sight board. Mordability Ad poinry z_(repWnlodby Wy rr•. (appointed by Cory Council) (depends on fund.used) Committee(appointed by Cory Council) {2mwan(puaita mlplen yys two(Fy2425) $104t mWon(FM) -fa minion levy Annual appropriations OM Amnia approprmwna plus Lost r.mrtlaleat taavwe eaal gab to ll*lmealan enMin.afl*) datelopar contribution* HOMHmbG (1MtdegOpar contributions,MOME/mac Leone(deWOOpm.M7and Development mans Iwnlopereet loam tomslderelopm•el)and aaM•garMate) amnia(a.maaq Strategic priority#2 Use Virginia Beach Leverage VBDA's newly granted authority to fund Development affordable housing activities Authority to fund Rnd opportunities to specifically align with aty's new large-scale, current and future economic development objectives mixed-use Short-term possibilities: development projects • Capacity building and pre-development grantanoana, strategic workforce development Long-term possibilities: • Low-mat construction financing.lax rebates,etc. September 26, 2023 9 • CITY COUNCIL'S BRIEFINGS HOUSING AFFORDABILITY STUDY UPDATE ITEM#74748 (Continued) • • Strategic priority#3 Design and Long-term investment in residents'knowledge, , incorporate housing understanding,and support for housing education campaign Important considerations: to corn plem ent • Be prepared to address immediate concerns com m unity • Community partners and ambassadors needed engagem ent plans • Use(but don't rely on)comprehensive plan update Full solution will include strategies for: • Evidence-based messaging and framing • When to use what data • Effective partner coordination The next two (2)slides provide Easy wins: • Easy win#1 Create a Housing Opportunity to take imm ediate action to address- Assistance Fund for housing affordability challenges for Oty'sworkers workers •Potential approach: • Allocate general funds for pilot program • Design program to use existing system(as much as possible) Full solution can address: • Range of funding levels and expected impact • • Options for funding uses(e.g.,DPA) • Ways to incorporate into long-term initiatives • September 26, 2023 10 CITY COUNCIL'S BRIEFINGS HOUSING AFFORDABILITY STUDY UPDATE ITEM#74748 (Continued) Easy win#2 Leverage Virginia Focus on mechanisms and incentives to bring in VVCLT Statewide and test CLT model in the Oty Com m unity Land glort-term actions: Trust to create • Recruit HR-I and other CDCa,identify development perm anent opportunities,allocate CDBG/HOME affordable horn eownershlp Long-term actions: opportunities • Align with Housing Assistance Fund and/or Housing Trust Fund,Incorporate into Workforce Housing Program The remaining slides provide Background work: 1ackground work tit Pursue innovative Problem:Rnandng affordable housing is very difficult self-sustaining Solution:Use public sector capacity to supplement(or mixed-income rental replace)oversubscribed federal resources development options In a nutshell: 1. City creates low-cost short/long term financing options 2. City partners with nonprofit/private developers on projects that deliver affordable housing ............................... ..... ... ..... . ... ... . . . 3. City can retain major ownership stake to collect revenue Significant long-term and and ensure long-term affordability homework assignment 4. Project Income can revolve into future developments September 26, 2023 11 CITY COUNCIL'S BRIEFINGS HOUSING AFFORDABILITY STUDY UPDATE ITEM#74748 (Continued) Montgom ery County,MD"Housing Production Fund" r County Mooring Developer bond Production team PRO.ECT iaauanca Fund Other public Can be: in hertm en Housing HPF.nd ether cons..uin. Opportunia•, debt replaced with permanent financing Pousts investment Nonprofit partner Gnwnfiuml For-profit Original HPF..tomwm mnHruaion ene� d•volop.r Mort lutun pratat. First HPF project:The Hu rston -. • 286 units directly next to Shady Grove Metro atop :WI ,.r • 81 units affordable at 50-65%AMI .i.-r. =IFIt{ 1 1 :Pr g • Ai.Includes•27.000 sett of office r21al 1s Pl • f !!!!!I- and retail apace ill!li a 7 it •111 / I :silo 9 ' • Public-private partnership: � pt : n County(HOC) • R tt A ■. o EYA and Boauto(private) Does not use LIHTC or any other -- - _ - public subsidy September 26, 2023 12 CITY COUNCIL'S BRIEFINGS HOUSING AFFORDABILITY STUDY UPDATE ITEM#74748 (Continued) -'ackground work#2 Research To be led by Department of Planning and opportunities to Community Development slm plify and Stormwater regulations and related fees can be stream line the major focus of this assessment perm fitting and Full solution can recommend: review processes • How to organize City functions into discrete phases to organize analysis • Ways to incorporate successful'green tape' programs and other expedited review • Beet approach to prioritize these improvements specifically for affordable housing Background work#3 Consider an To be led by Department of Planning and affordable housing Community Development advisory board to Proactively establish team to begin implementing guide the comprehensive plan strategies related to land use development of new and affordable housing zoning ordinance Advisory board could be single-purpose(with clear changes end goal),or sustained indefinitely end Workforce Housing Rogrem Full solution can cover: (nest slide) • Member representation goals • Workplan priorities end objectives • Feedback loops with community and other City boards September 26, 2023 13 CITY COUNCIL'S BRIEFINGS HOUSING AFFORDABILITY STUDY UPDATE ITEM#74748 (Continued) Use advisory board to One spedfic charge of advisory board can be assess options for reassessment of Workforce Housing Program redesigning Workforce Department of Housing and Neighborhood Housing Program to Preservation would play important role increase its im pact Full solution can cover: • Methods to examine success of past projects • Legal framework under current state law • Best practices for important policy design elements Feedback and discussion Mayor Dyer expressed his appreciation to Ms. Hill,Ms. Jones and Mr. Knopf for the presentation. • September 26, 2023 14 CITY COUNCIL'S BRIEFINGS 24-MONTH FOCUSED DRAFT ACTION PLAN ITEM#74749 3:50 P.M. Mayor Dyer welcomed Monica Croskey Chaparro, Assistant City Manager. Ms. Croskey Chaparro expressed her appreciation to City Council for their continued support: FY24-FY25 Focused Action Plan Monica Croskey Chaparro,Assistant City Manager I September 26,2023 The Ask •Are there any edits, revisions, or additions Council would like to see? •Once edits are made, how would Council like to affirm? FOCUSED ACTION PUN APAn P September 26, 2023 15 CITY COUNCIL'S BRIEFINGS 24-MONTH FOCUSED DRAFT ACTION PLAN ITEM#74749 (Continued) During the most recent City Council Retreat,focus areas suggested by City Council were recorded and sorted into categories: Land Use 21 �.,R;,,.t; - j�p.�� Affordable Housing 13 v' t. ' Budget 9 +L `'- l Flooding&Stormwater 9 Culture&Arts 8 u iikEsii� �� Mental&Physical Health 7 �' $n^ _ 1.t� Economic Vitality 6 w , Parks&Recreation 6 • Mrs —q�-w — ity _ Rudee Loop 6 • '-w7_ 1*.--r. . W-f', Council Policies&Processes 5 ..... . .V..r z—.�.,1 ' ;, Public Safety 5 300.3X3401011NM033.n 3 +II c— • •� tl�` ,s' • Land Use 21 rr ,1 4.;: . 1 4 ' ,� '"_� = Affordable Housing 13 RiR` 1 \�,''.1' n IC fi C Budget 9 �� Flooding&Stormwater 9 Culture&Arts 8 p 01 Mental&Physical Health 7 t• Economic Vitality 6 Parks&Recreation 6 R' _ ;1 Rudee Loop 6 S � ��. ` h 1 Council Policies&Processes 5 l it Public Safety 5 September 26, 2023 16 CITY COUNCIL'S BRIEFINGS 24-MONTH FOCUSED DRAFT ACTION PLAN ITEM#74749 (Continued) Here is a summary of the Speakup VB Survey results: Speakup VB Survey Sep.6-18 • 586 respondents,432 comments ='.NN ill• 29.. 1„,T• PM...Me d1.r o".ro III[w1V. III ..% s n% 9.w • Top 5(most/some focus): 9..,., d..d—N..9.'.,.,„.,.,„dd'«'..%..'111.1199% „% 9%9.• • Public safety(87%) .Fl•",,,—".—°'°".""""."'"''.."`— ... 26. 9%el • Flood protection/stormwater(82%) »..NMrr.MIIIII .,% m% ,%y • Land use(80%) L."'"""'6"""."..."drn"rn"6".1.1. IIMI .. N.:NdTs,...,..�ddNrn.N...1.1. IIMI 29. ..% %t • City budget(78%) •a,,,,,•-•,o.....— ,d. „%.,• • Affordable housing/housing E..",d.dMEll .,% 1b. .o.■ affordability and Homelessness(70%) ,0•••dw=I ,.% t'. 19% .". MPS • Comment Themes beyond Top 5: °".°"'°`'" °"'°""'"•"'MIIIIIM "` '"` '%" • Roads/sidewalks/transportation and •""°'°%9""*•••"°"2 "`"�""%'. •'% '� '�~ transit OR Ma •°" w" •Wa t'ma 9 d...d... ....d. %%d.d,. .%d.s. go., • Pickleball • Panhandling • Environmental stewardship waac%tmx PLAN MIT I f The top ten (10)focus areas below were categorized in three(3)groups, Govern, Envision and Invigorate: Land Use 21 VAffordable Housing 13 Budget 9 Flooding&Stormwater 9 Culture&Arts 8 Mental&Physical Health 7 -.-•_..- ` ' '`:ate. Economic Vitality 6 Parks&Recreation 6 Rudee Loop 6 Council Policies&Processes 5 Public Safety 5 s IIXUSW AC11CN PUN DRAFT I September 26, 2023 17 CITY COUNCIL'S BRIEFINGS 24-MONTH FOCUSED DRAFT ACTION PLAN ITEM#74749 (Continued) Here is an overview of the Govern category: To oversee the policy.actions end affairs of an organization reGYGGa ` •GvlOv MNk�M•'.YVNNnun..a.�',nvl •Ir.v.aY.rg4•Nµ•-Ivn.Yv'. V� �� . ., ., wrmuv k+a Irl'Y 11 RYrinvv •Hunan Ina sggMkf nE FIXY13DAR10e PLAY Dun I r Here is an overview of the Envision category: lrI ro:YGrY lb idr,,.e0*4 OF v,t,yarl0 detlit* aMlareyou kMntl to work towards ac.yo. 4Mr!•e dlrJL n4Ci Nq t'�i i..vi11N •lavJ v:. r�!• Wsnmy r orl`iM1iIR:..n�ugri�Mna •1\wevkl.vY.:r.\n1y.m.11 ttMY+w... xvt,r#o,.k.fl kwsl;p oW,10w'S1rt`v.Vli •464mr.ra..tnl11..a fnYHlv'n 4on"VI ar:rwta'nmlmYrrmw'.v I Mk+M1tN•M�awlrM.t arv:nl mrurmv .t.,•rnm Ax4:Inn:H dN MMv •Inxq.+lA4vi wNla.nni .1111•n September 26, 2023 18 CITY COUNCIL'S BRIEFINGS 24-MONTH FOCUSED DRAFT ACTION PLAN ITEM#74749 (Continued) Here is an overview of the Invigorate category: +� 114%11001KIE $s>_ ».k To hl lh..lt y9.M lull of. ..gy ID(O,IC • EebAea4WJ.mf.•wWWS W .UkEe.an on W'+roll+w m 4 1 .. •,.ww.t..Er.E m.e.ymutAr..e cCSf baAyyef MXmcas IN xCPoD Iwf.Twll'dY • .IU�'.vYly • 1 .r1...y.D wq"MA 014501.41: kr,t I 7 14) _ IO:USEDACIIDN RAN qU{I 19 _. aw Y 10[USID INIOISICKI TO Imagine MN tlY99 M OW E MIE W.MMtl...Mgt.*. .9va a .W✓F.w.m *JJ.Yw.w..f.n:e:.un .-.. .. r .....ell'.wall.. MOE To OM h99S9nMika Mw91.9 to fi` O..c.a.."..an,W Yva-,� .M....4 naav .......,....ell-., ED — September 26, 2023 19 CITY COUNCIL'S BRIEFINGS 24-MONTH FOCUSED DRAFT ACTION PLAN ITEM#74749 (Continued) Here are the questions the Body was asked: y4 Council Discussio . V • Are there any edits, revisions, ROMEor additions Council would like to see? • Once edits are made, how would Council like to affirm? Upon consensus of the Body, Mayor Dyer advised the Focus Action Plan will be affirmed through the adoption of a Resolution once all edits have been made and the Plan is finalized. Mayor Dyer expressed his appreciation to Ms. Croskey Chaparro for the presentation. September 26, 2023 20 CITY COUNCIL'S BRIEFINGS PENDING PLANNING ITEMS ITEM#74750 4:08 P.M. Mayor Dyer welcomed Kaitlen Alcock, Planning Administrator. Ms.Alcock expressed her appreciation to City Council for their continued support: 1........„.. i---n—rr—rryvarrrrrannrnrrovviraworinruinorarwlill NING October 17t CITY CIL MEETING VIRGINIA • =� BEACH There are fifteen (15)Planning Items scheduled for October 17`h: SUMMARY — October 17th 15 Planning Items Scheduled for City Council's Consideration 1. City of Virginia Beach • A Resolution to adopt and incorporate into the Virginia Beach Comprehensive Plan,2016,the Virginia Beach Historic "`"`••M`•' • Preservation Plan,2023 which will supersede the Historic ` +..•..i.••••w•. Resources Management Plan,1994 • Recommended for Approval by Planning Commission&Staff l 2&3.Commonwealth Brewing Company,LLC—District 9 1 • Street Closure&Modification of Conditions • Recommended for Approval by Planning Commission&Staff 4&5.W.W.RealtyAssodates,&Frank 7.Williams—District 2 • Modification of Conditions&Subdivision Variance(Section ......,..,^..,., ^^°'^^'_ 4.4(b(of the Subdivision Regulations( • Recommended for Approval by Planning Commission&Staff 6. Launch Creative Space,LLC—District 8 • Conditional Use Permit(Assembly Use) ) ' \ • Recommended for Approval by Planning Commission&Staff 7. Marina Shores Repair Corp—District 8 • Conditional Use Permit(Bulk Storage Yard • Recommended for Approval by Planning Commission&Staff '`•""•`� 2 VB September 26, 2023 21 CITY COUNCIL'S BRIEFINGS PENDING PLANNING ITEMS ITEM#74750 (Continued) SUMMARY — October 17th 15 Planning Items Scheduled for City Councils Consideration 8. Red Chords,Inc—DlstrIct3 • Modification of Conditions(Religious Use) • Recommended for Approval by Planning Commission&Staff •— •.. ,.� —.. . r••••• �. 9. Christopher Gregory—District 3 `�4.44"44.""• • Modification of Conditions .., r•••••••...... .. • Recommended for Approval by Planning Commission&Staff 10.Emily McGraw—District 8 • Conditional Use Permit(Tattoo Parlor) ., ••».•. • Recommended for Approval by Planning Commission&Staff 11. ehatt Brothers,LLC—District S %`L • . • • Conditional Use Permit(Tattoo Parlor) �` • Recommended for Approval by Planning Commission&Staff .—.:rr^r:4•n;,:--. 12.Wycliffe Presbyterian Church—District • Modification of Conditions(Religious Use) • Recommended for Approval by Staff and Denial by Planning Commission • 13,14,&15.Franklin Johnston Group Management&Development, LLC—District 2 • Conditional Rezoning(AG-1&AG-2 Agricultural Districts to Conditional A-18 Apartment District w/Workforce Housing "•w""c Overlay District),Modification of Proffers Subdivision Variance • Recommended for Approval by Staff,scheduled for Planning Commission on 10.11.2023 3 VB CITY OF VIRGINIA BEACH 1 A Resolution to adopt and incorporate into the Virginia Beach Comprehensive Plan, 2016, the Virginia Beach Historic Preservation Plan, 2023 which will supersede the Historic Resources Management Plan, 1994 Staff recommends Approval Planning Commission votedSAW recommend ARApproval '/VB September 26, 2023 22 CITY COUNCIL'S BRIEFINGS PENDING PLANNING ITEMS ITEM#74750 (Continued) • The Historic Preservation Plan,2023 was prepared by VIRGINIA BIM HI. Ic IRSOURCE4 MANACLMEST Pi AN Commonwealth Preservaton Group T* k • Public Input j • 2 virtual meetings • online survey(1,038 participants) C's. 1 • Supersedes the 1994 Historic Resources Management Plan • Meets state and federal standards for historic preservation planning • Builds on the City's successful preservation program,which has received statewide recognition HISTORIC PRESERVATION PLAN I S VI Y • The plan includes 8 objective areas with numerous actions and target outcomes identified under each area • Guiding Principles of the Plan include: • Preserving the City's cultural,historic and prehistoric resources '�' • Valuing and achieving equity,diversity,and Inclusion in the preservation program • Strengthening internal and external partnerships and /,;?,,, �' coordinating with complementary initiatives HISTORIC PRESERVATION PLAN 16 C September 26, 2023 23 CITY COUNCIL'S BRIEFINGS PENDING PLANNING ITEMS ITEM#74750 (Continued) COMMONWEALTH BREWING COMPANY, LLC & City Council:District 9 2 3 Location:Portion of the 50-foot right-of-way of Lake Drive,east of Pleasure House Road, 2440&2444 Pleasure House Road f 4 y W .'"'"-,I' b°,,, I ws^ I I g 9 tfi�'•Oy i 0 6 61. ss STREET CLOSURE&MODIFICATION OF CONDITIONS Staff recommends Approval Planning Commission voted- 0 0 to recommend Approval • Request to close the entire portion of Lake Drive east of Pleasure House Road rJ ' • Closure area will be incorporated into the applicant's /p '�'w° adjoining parcels and the City's pump station parcel for Cini — . ' — future expansion �i ra.wow., \e;�•• • Viewers'Meeting was held on April 27,2023,determined that the proposed closure will not result in any public �. °�J / "' j inconvenience Conditions are recommended to establish public drainage, swum • •. ^""' utilities,and access easements over the closed portion of the street for maintenance of the pump station t_/50 " "•, __ • No known opposition COMMONWEALTH BREWING COMPANY,ITC 18 VB September 26, 2023 24 CITY COUNCIL'S BRIEFINGS PENDING PLANNING ITEMS ITEM#74750 (Continued) I Parking Lot Outdoor Seating Expansion Area Expansion • A Modification of Conditions (014wAM1tlI IMwwcn) Proposed Street Closure Area request for an after-the-fact expansion of the outdoor seating �. _. \ areas and parking lots for the Craft Brewery I }l ! • The applicant has operated a Craft >++-. -•- I I �_. r Brewery since 2015,CUP approved in 2014 f 4' i 1 Convey to City for -Future Pump • In addition to after-the-fact Station Expansion permitting,conditions will require Ex-sting Brewery improvements from 2014 CUP ----:--- approval be completed COMMONWEALTH BREWING COMPARE LLC 19 Lv Parking Lot Outdoor Seating Expansion Area Expansion • 83 parking spaces are required;73 spaces are provided ,n.. .,,“ x _ .,=,i Proposed Street Closure Area • Alternative parking surface(gravel) _ requested for Parking Area E I • Condition proposed to require site r 1\ ./\ plan submittal within 90 days of CC ./ approval I I I ..r, _ • The Bayfront Advisory Commission Convey to City for (BAC)&Chesapeake Beach Civic II — Future Pump league are supportive of the Station Expansion Existing Brewery requests • 1 letter of support,1 letter of concern(noise,traffic,safety) `� COMMONWEALTH BREWING COMPANY;LLC 110 Cv September 26, 2023 25 CITY COUNCIL'S BRIEFINGS PENDING PLANNING ITEMS ITEM#74750 (Continued) W.W. REALTY ASSOCIATES, LLC & FRANK T. WILLIAMS City Council:District 2 4 & 5 Location:5309 Morris Neck Road&adjoining western parcel ( a a♦ IICALAI 611 MODIFICATION OF CONDITIONS&SUBDIVISION VARIANCE(Section 4.4(b)of the Subdivision Regulations) Staff recommends Approval Planning Commission voted a VB t � Parcel C-1"o:._.• i'v f Y r•own i— ` • Request for a Modification of Conditions(Alternative Rural Residential Development)to revise the boundary of the Agricultural/Open Space Preservation Easement to encumber all of the western 30-acre parcel(Parcel A-1) • Boundaries of the easement were not adjusted during the 2013 Subdivision Variance approval W.W.REALTY ASSOCIATES,LLC&FRANK.T.WILLIAMS 112 VB September 26, 2023 26 CITY COUNCIL'S BRIEFINGS PENDING PLANNING ITEMS ITEM#74750 (Continued) ,,,,,h . -a. --- -- • Request for a Subdivision Variance for ----- '2's lot width&street line frontage for Parcel �'— D-1,reduced from 60 feet to 50 feet 1 !D 1 7.7 :,I • Reconfigure property lines shifting Parcel p -f 3- i C-i to the south,and shifting the access .fi11+3--- NE I to Parcel D-1 to the north of Parcel C-1 - - ' • Parcel C-1,meets all dimensional _.�_ t: - i requirements and will be developed with 1 single-family dwelling s i • -••• __ JJ _r_ • Parcel to ekiva fe ......-1,-- - � cannotD-1 be developedrmaina forcu residentiatedil useld, emu '_` • No known o pposition vv.IA..htr.,I ASSOCIATES,LLC S FRANK.T.WILLIAMS 113 VA_ LAUNCH CREATIVE SPACE, LLC M City Council:District 8 6 Location:2865 Lynnhaven Drive,Suite Cl _ { e. ♦ i r. T o E ,.�..,•,.e... - �� CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT(Assembly Use) Staff recommends Approval Planning Commission to recommend Approval lA VB September 26, 2023 27 CITY COUNCIL'S BRIEFINGS PENDING PLANNING ITEMS ITEM#74750 (Continued) '47""^"'�'—" • Request for a Conditional Use �'-.�, wiPethin for xian Assembly 1,500 Use 64q� within an existing sq ft soft 7---- tunit i � . �� • Small events will be hosted !� such as birthday parties,baby fit' i. ' showers,corporate events a ,‘. a -A � EL".4 _ - _ • Maximum of 50 guests per I J M a,,MIEN , ■,...,, event anticipated;final occupancy to be determined by the Fire Marshal Suite C1 1,500 SF LAUNCH CMEATNE SMCt,UC 115 Ng '40ita..'*;;;1111rtt _ 4i I"\1°\ii • No kitchen proposed onsite • Parking requirement met onsite • No outdoor events or outdoor amplified • No known opposition music permitted LAUNCH CREATIVE SM[E,LIC 116 VB September 26, 2023 28 CITY COUNCIL'S BRIEFINGS PENDING PLANNING ITEMS ITEM#74750 (Continued) MARINA SHORES REPAIR CORP. ITEM City Council:District 8 7 Location:2865 Lynnhaven Drive � a I�q a i ; 4 E • {. N¢ { � t� „ 8 —-• • �.I \ \�I�" e s e "•••••.sue • CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT(Bulk Storage Yard) Staff recommends AP rp oval Planning Commission wad to recommend Approval VB • Request for a Conditional Use Permit for • •..tp•y• F Bulk Storage yard for seasonal outdoor A � yr�r storage of certain merchandise and year- ' Ti 11y# rr,-y 1 round storage of mulch •"F �r .+ nxet :t * ▪ Seasonal merchandise to be stored r ti. • 1p i 1 b"" t outdoors under a temporary tent during n 4 •','I' the following periods. • ¢i' • March 20°to May 15'" • November 20'"to December 15'" • • , " • No sales to be conducted outdoors 1.11.1 tt!' '� l' , ' • - 3 • Requested deviation to landscape 500 ry'"-0 `• j , screening: f�„• ? _ • No plantings around mulch dr9,�ttt\ enclosure • • 4.5-foot tall opaque fence around �t mulch rather than 6-foot tall fence Ciij �,M i IP • No plantings or fencing around temporary merchandise location MARINA SHORES REPAIR CORPI 18 WI September 26, 2023 29 CITY COUNCIL'S BRIEFINGS PENDING PLANNING ITEMS ITEM#74750 (Continued) Proposed Mulch 4. „s l Location \ i ' Fd ti Proposed Tent it 6 S ` .� Location *eh • Storage areas located in existing parking spaces: • Sufficient parking met for the shopping center with the o Seasonal storage area to occupy 8 parking spaces 12 spaces occupied by merchandise o Permanent mulch storage area to occupy 4 parking • No known opposition spaces MARINA SHORES REPAIR CORP 119 WI RED CHURCH, INC ITEM City Council:District 3 8 Location:245 South Rosemont Road e A- , 9: b r f t irA.r,• MODIFICATION OF CONDITIONS Staff recommends Approval - Planning Commission to recommend Approval 30 VB September 26, 2023 30 CITY COUNCIL'S BRIEFINGS PENDING PLANNING ITEMS ITEM#74750 (Continued) . __ • Request for a Modification of Conditions to _ _ �- construct a 15,750 sf addition to the existing church • Addition to provide a new 616-seat ^� n.xv l sanctuary usrvmrv6w0 • r Existing square footage of classroom space _..I I used by a daycare program to remain the same t- 'S2 -' - I I • 3 access points from South Rosemont Road 0 - ^-^ -- to be retained: 111:• =:.i;` I • North and south driveways to be -••"s- altered for right exit only 1 i V• •r, I • Shared Parking Study approved by the : _ Zoning Administrator to reduce the f •t,_s. 4w. . required minimum parking s., RED CHURCH,INCI 21 Nal r �� I4 s L_ • Materials for addition and renovation of • Existing steeple and porch to be removed existing building to include: • Height to be similar to existing o EIFS • Signage to conform to Zoning Ordinance o Corrugated and perforated metal panels • No known opposition,9 letters of support o Aluminum storefront RED CHURCH.INCI 22 VB September 26, 2023 • 31 CITY COUNCIL'S BRIEFINGS PENDING PLANNING ITEMS ITEM#74750 (Continued) CHRISTOPHER GREGORY ITEM City Council:District 3 9 Location:5152&5168 Princess Anne Road • � v i "•wr { 0 1p w aX p w • MODIFICATION OF CONDITIONS Staff recommends Approval Planning Commission voted. 23 VB EtaI xtl'long-with brick maxim base - ....... prior axsim-nd brick xgP tail external ilumination-ground mounted lighting rrr..,..... I, ........,...A u.. SHOPPES at KEMPS LANDING r I wvawr 5152 5 i.wrrww • Request to install two identical free-standing signs at the • Double-sided signs with external,ground-mounted Shoppes at Kemps Landing illumination • Property zoned B-6K Historic Kempsville Area Mixed Use • White sign faces with black typeface District • 8 feet tall,10 feet wide CHRISTOPHER GREGORY 12a VB September 26, 2023 32 CITY COUNCIL'S BRIEFINGS PENDING PLANNING ITEMS ITEM#74750 (Continued) 4 i , One sign perpendicular to Princess Anne s t!c _�:i H�. Road �?" �N .� ' �8� '�� '•� i.\\_.- • One sign perpendicular to S.Witchduck $2i—_44 faIV:, Cfs+1..r di ✓ Road 0`, -4%,'. :t F ` •J • Colors and materials compatible with �ziv -/i f shopping center architecture � t' <`'��l ,'''jr +. J ,i 1 t No known opposition CII165IOPRIER GREGORY 125 VB EMILY MCGRAW M City Council:District 8 10 Location:3636 Virginia Beach Boulevard ... � ...gip = r 3 p1•err. _ \ lk 1 +r�� CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT(Tattoo Parlor) Staff recommends Approval Planning Commission vot ommend royal 26 VB September 26, 2023 33 CITY COUNCIL'S BRIEFINGS PENDING PLANNING ITEMS ITEM#74750 (Continued) , •IT� Iw 11v- 1 It • .z'�.w • • Request for a Conditional Use Permit for 1 i �r �b a Tattoo Parlor �• SS r 44 j ,. t ' _ t • Located inside an existing beauty salon w. ' • Hours of Operation: • - • • f ' ' • 9:00 am to 9:00 pm Monday to '^ YI• "., s'' _ ° q,Ci' ' • pp � r •L d a � 'S'e. Saturday �.. , � � � i'.-11 ) By appointment only \e• • . awo EMILY MCGRAWI 27 V3 • Sufficient parking onsite;a parking variance was granted to the shopping center in 2007 • 4 letters of support received from adjacent business tenants • No known opposition EMILY MCGRAWI 28 ✓B September 26, 2023 34 CITY COUNCIL'S BRIEFINGS PENDING PLANNING ITEMS ITEM#74750 (Continued) BHATT BROTHERS, LLC ,,,:i.:,,,:„, City Council:District 5 1 1 Location:1169 Nimmo Parkway,Suite 224 •,♦ P (\ k /� F "1 'a pa •�h ��♦� • / ♦ ;r n. d - L/ �' ,, I , , t CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT(Tattoo Parlor) Staff recommends Approval Planning Commission voted ^' commend Approval .q fig,:•14 t�4\y. . ''t•'!:`°, T •• Request for a Conditional Use Permit for a;,y f t�i7:A' w A.,1 i,I��+.,r a Tattoo Parlor /1 ^+H -v - 4 y1t' • Located inside existing beauty salon,use 1, ,,f�, i will occur within 32 private suites,all H�'' � averaging 135 square feet. r w l• 4,i' y .", Hours of Operation: •iW. s v ,, . • • • 9:00 am to 9:00 pm Monday to ys !' ,: ! Saturday iar '^1 s o s4 ' y By appointment only R•Iv A _. 4 •.. MATT BROTHERS,LLC I 30 D September 26, 2023 35 CITY COUNCIL'S BRIEFINGS PENDING PLANNING ITEMS ITEM#74750 (Continued) n fir. .. ^ •i. _.ram • Sufficient parking on site • No exterior changes proposed to the building or signage • No known opposition IS EMIT BROTHERS,LLC 131 YS WYCLIFFE PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH ITEM City Council:District 8 12 Location:1445 North Great Neck Road,2307 Millwood Road,parcel between 2307&2309 Millwood Road t ,, , G �' yy,: ..✓ c a MODIFICATION OF CONDITIONS(Religious Use) Staff recommends Approval Planning Commission 4 to recommend Denial 32 VB September 26, 2023 36 CITY COUNCIL'S BRIEFINGS PENDING PLANNING ITEMS ITEM#74750 (Continued) ' .,.,4&118.40y.A ' I' r _,elf__ __ _ _ - -- • i • Requesting a Modification of Conditions of a Conditional Use Permit for a Religious Use approved by City Council on August 3,1966 • Church has existed on the existing three parcels since the 1960's • Subsequent modifications approved in 1988 and 2000 for a childcare education center and church addition ��p WYCUFFE PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH!33 R9 T 1 _- • Requesting to reduce the boundary ,� of the church by approximately i-. _-Z.._a.•= 3.88-acres ) -- Y • 4.13 acres of the property will "'- =•=�-- remain under the church's R-10 I • =_? _-"^..... ownership • (• ,"eu - • Property will continue to exceed the Parcel B-1-A-1 I Parcel B-2-A-1 I L ._. .-. 3-acre minimum lot area Church Property 1 Property r-_.:_. �=- requirement for Religious Uses,per to Remain !Removed from CUP ..".,....*-._. Section 240.1 of the Zoning (4.132 acres) i (3.879 acres) I • 18 speakers spoke in opposition at I /P/f. ""' Planning Commission,36 letters of /4•;' opposition —1• ••:� — —•� . _.:;;,...;,•;;;,_'' • Concern with development on the _ o;:0.:.,, property to be sold including "'" +•�- potential environmental impacts �p W ��_8r YCUFFE PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH I34 September 26, 2023 37 CITY COUNCIL'S BRIEFINGS PENDING PLANNING ITEMS ITEM#74750 (Continued) FRANKLIN JOHNSTON GROUP MANAGEMENT & ITEMS DEVELOPMENT, LLC 13, 14, & 15 City Council:District 2 Location.2737 Princess Anne Road&eastern adjoining parcel,2520 Allie Nicole Circle CONDITIONAL REZONING (AG-1&AG-2 Agricultural Districts to Conditional A-18 Apartment District w/Workforce Housing Overlay District),MODIFICATION OF PROFFERS, SUBDIVISION VARIANCE Staff recommends Approval scheduled for P • 35 VB • A Conditional Rezoning of 6.26 acres TO :.5i i from AG-1&AG-2 to Conditional A-18 ------ _• _ ;aea. w/Workforce Housing Overlay District& a Modification of Proffers to add 176 FOIT'4 W J " s''N•' ‘Ti+�,rr, t- additional units • " '` '• i. • Total of 416 units(Phase 1—240 units, Phase 2—176 units)with an overall density of 18.94 units/acre s • 30%of the units in Phase 2 are - designated for workforce housing—53 • units • Western portion of property lies within the LTA and 65-70 dB noise zone _ - ' • -- './ • All residential units are located outside ... I. of the ITA and AICUZ noise zone SOUTHERN PINES . • Application was presented to the 1RP on - ^^•°°•°•°°• September 20,2023.JRP Is supportive of the proposal FRANKLIN JOHNSTON GROUP MANAGEMENT&DEVELOPMENT,LLC 136 w� September 26, 2023 38 CITY COUNCIL'S BRIEFINGS PENDING PLANNING ITEMS ITEM#74750 (Continued) .-. J f , taxi ri —it ,G • Princess Anne Rd is designated as ? ,• F •,,,, * '.t.,4: = access controlled; applicant J3 ` - pli c,l request-outapprovalaccess of right- . � l} •• in/right-out ac point • Primary access proposed from g_ a George Wythe Drive r;_ • Parking ratio of 1.73 spaces/unit is _ i fair."—* * >,,.,_ approved by Zoning Administrator— 741 spaces required;719 provided ISOUTHERN PINES \ _ _ _._._FRANKLIN JOHNSTON GROUP MANAGEMENT&DEVELOPMENT,SIC 137 `e8 EXISTING PROPOSED zaR ate LOT A-t { LOTA Q '•-4 viit a OTB4 LOTS —George Wyllie Drive —Geage Wyl,,e Drive • 2737 Princess Anne Rd,created in 1975,does meet current minimum street line frontage&lot width for a parcel in the AG-1/AG-2 district;minimum street line frontage is 120 feet;minimum lot width is 150 feet • Existing frontage&lot width is 25.18 feet and will be unchanged with this application • Proposed resubdivision does not increase the degree of nonconformity `Q FRANKLIN JOHNSTON GROUP MANAGEMENT&DEVELOPMENT,LLC 138 Rg September 26, 2023 39 CITY COUNCIL'S BRIEFINGS PENDING PLANNING ITEMS ITEM#74750 (Continued) ztiv, It _verl}ead lF'icy epgh- L �,. • 5 apartment buildings proposed—one,3-story building along Princess Anne Rd and four,4-story buildings with a maximum height of 55' • Requesting a deviation to the 35'maximum height requirement in the A-18 Apartment District FRANKLIN JOHNSTON GROUP MANAGEMENT&DEVELOPMENT,LW 139 W a g �� ��j S la r - •- a : •- • n• . .• -V....f i, •. . iF�'wrAN try View Princes •- •... f s _> • Landscape berm to be provided along Princess Anne Road • 6 letters of opposition,including 1 from the TA/ITA CAC noting concerns related to height,density,and parking FRANKLINIOHNSTON GROUP MANAGEMENT&DEVELOPMENT,U[I A0 IS Mayor Dyer expressed his appreciation to Ms.Alcockfor the presentation. September 26, 2023 40 CITY COUNCIL DISC USSION/INITIATIVES/COMMENTS ITEM#74751 4:59 P.M. Vice Mayor Wilson advised as this is Council Member Holcomb's last meeting as a City Council Member, she wanted to express her appreciation to him for being a part of City Council and bringing so much wisdom to the Body and he will be missed. Council Member Holcomb expressed it has been his pleasure and has been humbled by the,opportunity to serve as a Member of this Body and the citizens in District 1. Council Member Holcomb advised he is looking forward to now serving the entire City as Sheriff Mayor Dyer advised Council.Member Holcomb has not only served on this Body but has served as a member in the House of Delegates and will now go on to serve as Sheriff which all represents a continuum of public service. Mayor Dyer expressed his appreciation to Council Member.Holcomb and wished him the very best. September 26, 2023 41 CITY COUNCIL DISCUSSION/INITIATIVES/COMMENTS ITEM#74752 (Continued) Council Member Ross-Hammond provided the following updates: - The Department of Education announced St. Gregory, the Great Catholic School as a 2023 National Blue Ribbon Award winner - Advised she and Council Member Berlucchi attended last Sunday's service at the Global Outreach Church, expressing it was very nice to see them recognizing Hispanic Heritage Month by singing in Spanish Advised the $150,000 allocated for District 4 will be used to create African American heritage signs throughout the City and expressed her appreciation to Planning Department staff, Kathy Warren -Director, Emily Archer—Project Coordinator and Mike Anaya -Planner,for their help in designing the first one dedicated for Burton Station. Council Member Ross-Hammond advised the signs will be built in sets of four - (4) and will total fifteen (15),once completed - Advised she and Council Member Rouse recently attended an event at the site for the Tri- Campus-where the new school will be built to combine 4`h`and 5`h`grade students from Betty F. Williams and 6`"grade students from Bayside Elementary Schools. Council Member Berlucchi expressed his appreciation to Pastor Cunningham and the congregation for being so welcoming. Council Member Berlucchi advised it was a fantastic experience to see how,different countries are recognized each week and prayed for. • September 26, 2023 42 CITY COUNCIL DISCUSSION/INITIATIVES/COMMENTS ITEM#74753 (Continued) Vice Mayor Wilson advised she attended the groundbreaking event where Governor Youngkin announced that Amazon will launch a new, state-of-the-art fulfillment center and delivery station in the City. Vice Mayor Wilson advised it was a big event with Congresswoman Kiggans, Senator DeSteph,Delegate Knight and six (6) Members of City Council there. Vice Mayor Wilson added, this is expected to bring approximately 1,000 jobs to the City and is great for District 5. September 26, 2023 43 CITY COUNCIL DISCUSSION/INITIATIVES/COMMENTS ITEM#74754 (Continued) Council Member Berlucchi advised last night there was an Emergency Management Service (EMS) graduation ceremony held for three (3) classes and expressed his appreciation for all of them. Council Member Taylor advised he was impressed with the number and diversity of graduates and shows how hard the City is working to answer calls. September 26, 2023 44 CITY COUNCIL DISCUSSION/INITIATIVES/COMMENTS ITEM#74755 (Continued) Council Member Berlucchi advised that last week the Mayor Jennifer Gilmour and Chief Executive Stephen Reid from of Ards and North Down Borough,Northern Ireland, UK visited with ten (10)students. Council Member Berlucchi advised they have been a Sister City since 2001 and it was nice to share information about each of the Cities and see so many similarities. • September 26, 2023 45 CITY COUNCIL DISCUSSION/INITL4TIVES/COMMENTS ITEM#74756 (Continued) Council Member Taylor reminded the Body of the "Culture Meets Commerce" event he will host on September 28`I' at the Yendidi African Restaurant with special guest,Council Member Berlucchi. Council Member Taylor advised the event will give artists and business owners an opportunity to visit avenue with cultural backgrounds and:bring commerce together. • September 26, 2023 46 _ CITY COUNCIL DISCUSSION/INITIATIVES/COMMENTS ITEM#74757 (Continued) Council Member Wooten advised she and Council Member Taylor attended the graduation ceremony held at the HIVE Center for young entrepreneurs and it was very nice to see the HIVE being used for the purpose it was created in supporting entrepreneurs and business owners. Council Member Wooten advised there were seven graduates between the ages of nine(9)and thirteen(13)years old and recognized each of them and their businesses. Council Member Wooten expressed her appreciation to Ihsane Mouak, Workforce Development Coordinator,for her excellent leadership and believes the HIVE Center is truly a jewel in the City. • September 26, 2023 47 CITY COUNCIL DISCUSSION/INITL4 TI VES/COMMENTS ITEM#74758 (Continued) Council Member Henley advised she will host her monthly District 2 Forum on September 28t''from 5:15 — 7:00 P.M, in Building 19, and invited anyone interested to attend. September 26, 2023 48 CITY COUNCIL DISCUSSION/INITIATIVES/COMMENTS ITEM#74759 (Continued) Mayor Dyer announced the City has been ranked by Wallet Hub's Best-Run Cities in America as 22"d and 3rd in the "Quality of Services" category. Mayor Dyer expressed his appreciation to the Body and City staff for their work and dedication in making the City one of the most livable and safest places to live. • September 26, 2023 49 ITEM#74760 Mayor Robert M.Dyer entertained a motion to permit City Council to conduct its CLOSED SESSION, pursuant to Section 2.2-3711(A), Code of Virginia, as amended,for the following purpose: PERSONNEL MATTERS: Discussion, consideration, or interviews of prospective candidates for - employment, assignment, appointment, promotion, performance, demotion, salaries, disciplining or resignation of specific public officers, appointees or employees of any public body pursuant to Section 2.2-3711(A)(1) • Council Appointments: Council, Boards, Commissions, Committees,Authorities,Agencies and Appointees • Performance of Council Appointees • September 26, 2023 50 • ITEM#74760 . , nue(Con h' d) Upon motion by Vice Mayor Wilson,seconded by Council Member Berlucchi,City Council voted to proceed into CLOSED SESSION at 5:16 P.M. • • • Voting: :10- 0 Council Members.Voting.Aye: Michael F.Berlucchi,Mayor Robert M Dyer,Barbara M.Henley,N.D. "Rocky" Holcomb, Dr. Amelia N. Ross-Hammond, Jennifer Rouse, Joashua F. "Joash" Schulman,-Chris Taylor, Vice Mayor Rosemary Wilson and Sabrina D. Wooten Council Members Absent: Robert W..,"Worth"Remick • Closed Session 5:16 P.M. — 5:29 P.M. September 26,.2023 51 CERTIFICATION ITEM#74761 Mayor Dyer RECONVENED the Formal Session. Upon motion by Council Member Rouse, seconded by Council Member Holcomb, City Council CERTIFIED THE CLOSED SESSION TO BE IN WITH THE MOTION TO RECESS Only public business matters lawfully exempt from Open Meeting requirements by Virginia law were discussed in Closed Session to which • this certification resolution applies. AND, Only such public business matters as were identified in the motion convening the Closed Session were heard, discussed or considered by Virginia Beach City Council. Voting: 10- 0 Council Members Voting Aye: Michael F. Berlucchi,Mayor Robert M.Dyer, Barbara M. Henley,'N. D. 'Rocky" Holcomb, Dr. Amelia N. Ross-Hammond, Jennifer Rouse, Joashua F. "Joash" Schulman, Chris Taylor, Vice Mayor Rosemary Wilson and Sabrina D. Wooten Council Members Absent: Robert W. "Worth"Remick September 26, 2023 �Nv+9�qc S�� � yL"t1 E Sc •GF OYY X1Y� RESOLUTION CERTIFICATION OF CLOSED SESSION VIRGINIA BEACH CITY COUNCIL WHEREAS: The Virginia Beach City Council convened into CLOSED SESSION, pursuant to the affirmative vote recorded in ITEM#74760 on Page 50 and in accordance with the provisions of The Virginia Freedom of Information Act; and, WHEREAS:Section 2.2-3712 of the Code of Virginia requires a certification by the governing body that such Closed Session was conducted in conformity with Virginia law. NOW, THEREFORE,BE IT RESOLVED:That the Virginia Beach City Council hereby certifies that, to the best of each member's knowledge, (a) only public business matters lawfully exempted from Open Meeting requirements by Virginia law were discussed in Closed Session to which this certification resolution applies; and, (b) only such public business matters as were identified in the motion convening this Closed Session were heard, discussed or considered by Virginia Beach City Council. Amanda Barnes, City Clerk September 26, 2023 52 ADJOURNMENT ITEM#74762 Mayor Robert M. Dyer DECLARED the City Council FORMAL SESSION ADJOURNED at 5:30 P.M. Perri FI C elius Chief Deputy City Clerk A d Barnes Robert M. Dyer City Clerk, MMC Mayor City of Virginia Beach Virginia September 26, 2023