HomeMy WebLinkAboutII. A. COMPREHENSIVE LOCAL SAFETY ACTION PLAN 8.27.24Comprehensive Local Road Safety Action Plan
Katie Shannon PE, Engineer V
Ric Lowman PE, Traffic Engineer
Devin Simpson PE, Kimley-Horn
August 27, 2024
•Comprehensive roadway safety plan
•Aims to improve safety for all road users
•Data-driven, equitable approach
•Result of combination of two initiatives:
•Citywide need for Comprehensive Roadway Safety Plan
•Identify safety improvements for Future State and
Federal grant eligibility, Compliance with the U.S. DOT
Safe Streets and Roadways for All (SS4A) program.
Local Road Safety Action Plan Overview
2
July 11, 2023 – Safety Update to Council
•Noted traffic fatalities are increasing despite total crashes decreasing
•Identified a need for action and a comprehensive approach to safety
August 2023 – Local Road Safety Action Plan Kickoff
•Builds upon existing traffic safety improvements program by identifying
systemic improvements to reduce fatal and serious injury crashes
•Example Systemic Countermeasures:
•Pedestrian-Related: Leading Pedestrian Intervals, Pedestrian Hybrid Beacons
•Speed-Related: Lane Width Reductions in Urban Areas, Wider Edge Lines
Initiatives for Roadway Safety 2023
3
National Roadway Safety
A 2021 news article for
Insurance Institute for
Highway Safety reported:
•“Pandemic lockdowns made rush-
hour speeding, risky driving the new
normal”
•A total of 42,939 people died in
motor vehicle crashes in 2021, which
is a 10% increase from 2020
•The per capita death rate increased
9% compared to 2020
4
Virginia Beach Safety
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
7000
Fatalities per YearCrashes/Injuries per YearCrashes, Injuries and Fatalities in Virginia
Beach, 2012-2022
Crashes Injuries Fatalities
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
20
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
Fatalities per YearCrashes/Injuries per YearSpeed-Related Crashes, Injuries and Fatalities
in Virginia Beach, 2012-2022
Crashes Injuries Fatalities
Source: Commonwealth of Virginia, Virginia Traffic Crash Facts – 2012-2022; Virginia Department of Motor Vehicles 5
Virginia Beach Safety – Pedestrians
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
7000
Crashes/Injuries per YearPedestrian Fatalities in Virginia Beach, 2013-2022
Crashes Pedestrian Fatalities
6
Safe Streets and Roads for All (SS4A)
•Introduced as part of the Bipartisan Infrastructure Bill
•Program administered by the U.S. Department of
Transportation Program
•Provides grants to local, regional, and Tribal communities
as part of a systematic approach to prevent deaths and
serious injuries on the nation’s roadways
•$5 Billion in Funding Over 5 Years (2022-2026):
•Safety Action Plans (Step 1)
•Implementation Grants (Step 2)
SS4A Requirements:
Target Goal
Task Force
Safety Analysis
Equity Analysis
Engagement
Plan Adoption
7
Plan
Timeline
Kickoff
(August 2023)
Data Collection
(September 2023)
Safety and
Equity Analysis
(November 2023 to
January 2024)
Community Meeting
#1
(November 2023)
Countermeasure
Identification
(February 2024)
Countermeasure
Prioritization
(March 2024)
Community Meeting
#2
(March 2024)
Stakeholder
Workshop
(March 2024)
Documentation
(April to July 2024)
Public Comment
(August/September
2024)
Adoption of Plan by
Planning Commission
into Comp Plan
(September 2024)
Adoption of Plan by
City Council
(October 2024)
8
1.Goals and Objectives
2.Engagement and Collaboration
3.Safety Analysis
4.Equity Considerations
5.Project Identification and Prioritization
6.Progress and Transparency
Plan Components
DOCUMENTATION
9
Goals and Objectives
TARGET GOAL
The City of Virginia
Beach aims to reduce
fatal and serious
injury crashes by half
by 2055 with an aim
toward zero beyond
2055.
OBJECTIVES
1.Reduce Fatal and Serious Injury
Crashes
2.Maximize Opportunities to Fund
Safety-Related Roadway
Improvements
3.Promote Public Awareness of
Roadway Safety
4.Implement an Equitable Approach
to Safety Improvements
10
Collaboration: Task Force
Task Force
•Formed to guide the plan
development and support
implementation
•Included representatives from:
•Public Works
•Planning and Community
Development
•Parks and Recreation
•Police
•HRTPO
11
•Meetings
Plan Introduction and Goal Setting
Engagement Input and Preliminary
Findings
Emphasis Area Analyses and Scoring
Countermeasures and Strategies
Engagement Input and Plan Framework
Engagement: Community Meetings
A hybrid approach to community engagement was taken for this plan,
which included in-person meetings and online activities.
Community Meeting #1
•November 16, 2023
•Solicited input on transportation-related safety needs via a survey and interactive mapping activity
•Generally, concerns noted were diverse but several including pedestrians and speeding
Community Meeting #2
•March 20, 2024
•Solicited input on the
proposed systemic
countermeasures
•Generally, majority of
input was positive and
supportive
12
Engagement: Stakeholder Workshop
Stakeholder Workshop
•Held March 22, 2024
•Provided businesses and organizations
the opportunity to provide their unique
perspectives
•Coordinated with representatives from:
•Hampton Roads Transit
•U.S. Navy
•Bayfront Advisory Group
•Resort Advisory Group
•Central Business District Association
•Sentara Health
•Southern VB – Rural
•Virginia Beach Public Schools 13
What We Heard
•Desire for more pedestrian and
bicycle facilities
•Desire for increased
enforcement and traffic
calming measures
•Desire for improved roadway
lighting
Project Identification
Location-Targeted Countermeasures
1.Selected top 5 intersections and top 6 segments for further review in
collaboration with traffic engineering
2.Performed desktop review of historical crash patterns and existing conditions
3.Identified proven countermeasures to reduce crash potential at each location
Systemic Countermeasures
•Intended to be applied broadly across the City
•Aimed to cover each Emphasis Area
•A blend of engineering treatments and strategic initiatives
14
Identified Systemic Countermeasures
MOTORCYCLISTS
[Enhance Traffic Signal
Detections, High Friction
Surface Treatment of
Curves]
HEAVY VEHICLES
[Protected Left-Turns,
Access Management
Improvements]
PEDESTRIANS
[Crosswalks, LPIs,
Sidewalks, Median
Barriers]
IMPAIRED DRIVING
[Traffic Safety
Checkpoints, Impaired
Driver Campaigns]
BICYCLISTS
[Greenways and Trails
Multimodal enhancements,
Pedestrian Safety Campaigns]
UNPROTECTED
OCCUPANTS
[Seatbelt Enforcement,
Child Restraint
Resources]
ROADWAY DEPARTURES
[Guardrails, Improve
Clear Zones, Rumble
Strips]
UNSIGNALIZED
INTERSECTIONS
[Enhance Pavement
Markings, Lighting, Improve
sight distance, Innovative
Intersections]
SCHOOL ZONES
[Recommend Optimal
Crossing Guard Staffing
and Circulation Plans]
YOUTH AND
INEXPERIENCED
DRIVERS
[Enforcement of Virginia
Laws For Youth and
Inexperienced Drivers]
RURAL ROADWAY
[Upgraded Guardrail,
Pavement Markers,
Enhance Intersections]
SIGNALIZED
INTERSECTIONS
[Enhanced Detection,
Pedestrian Amenities, Left
Turn Phasing, Restricted
Rights on Red]
SPEEDING
[Traffic Calming
Measures; Speed
Cameras]
ADULT AND AGING
ROAD USERS
[Transit options in Mayor’s
Commission on Aging -
Senior Housing & Resource
Guide, Microtransit]
EMPHASIS AREA
[ENGINEERING TREATMENT COUNTERMEASURES]
EMPHASIS AREA
[STRATEGIC INITIATIVE COUNTERMEASURES]
15
High Priority Intersections and Segments
Holland Rd &
Rosemont Rd
Birdneck Rd &
Virginia Beach
Blvd
Newtown Rd
& Baker Rd
Lynnhaven
Pkwy &
Salem Rd
Ferrell Pkwy
& Pleasant
Valley Rd
Bonney Rd
[Independence Blvd
to Boggs Ave]
Salem Rd
[Landstown Rd to
North Landing Rd]
Pacific Ave
[5th St to 16th St]
Pacific Ave
[16th St to 31st St]
Sandbridge Rd
[Flanagan’s Ln to
Colechester Rd]
Northampton Blvd
[Diamond Springs
Rd to Norfolk Line]
Signalized Intersections
Upgrade Lighting, Access Management,
Flashing Yellow Arrows, Extend Median
Signalized Intersections
Increase All-Red Clearance Interval,
Protected LT, Innovative Intersection
Signalized Intersections
Increase All-Red Clearance Interval,
Flashing Yellow Arrows, Upgrade Crosswalks
Signalized Intersections
Increase All-Red Clearance Interval,
Restrict RT
Signalized Intersections
Increase All-Red Clearance Interval,
Restrict RT, Upgrade Lighting
Signalized Intersections
Innovative Intersection, or
Protected Left TurnsRoadway Departures
Shoulder Widening, Raised Pavement Markings,
Guardrail Along Curves
Unsignalized Intersections
Upgrade Lighting, Sight Distance
Improvements
Unsignalized Intersections
Lighting Upgrades, Pedestrian Refuges,
LT Lanes at 17th and 22nd
Unsignalized Intersections | Roadway Departures
Lighting, Roadway Widening, Pavement Markings
Pedestrians | Speeding
Median Fence/Barriers, Wider Edge
Lines, Speed Reduction Strategies
High Ranking Intersections Scored by Priority Matrix
Countermeasures
High Ranking Segments Scored by Priority Matrix
Countermeasures
16
Project Prioritization
Category Category
Weight
Points
Available Subcategory Evaluation Metric Points
Safety 65 35
Safe System
Approach
Promotes the Safe System Approach (Safer Vehicles, Safer Speeds, Safer Roads, Post-Crash Care, Safer People)5
Does Not Promote the Safe System Approach (Safer Vehicles, Safer Speeds, Safer Roads, Post-Crash Care, Safer People)0
Fatalities and
Serious
Injuries
Applicable Emphasis Area(s) Experienced 15% or More Fatal or Serious Injury Crashes 15
Applicable Emphasis Area(s) Experienced 5% or More Fatal or Serious Injury Crashes 10
Applicable Emphasis Area(s) Experienced Less Than 5% Fatal or Serious Injury Crashes 5
Risk
Applicable Emphasis Area(s) Accounts for 15% or More of Citywide 5-Year Crashes 15
Applicable Emphasis Area(s) Accounts for 5% or More of Citywide 5-Year Crashes 10
Applicable Emphasis Area(s) Accounts for Less Than 5% of Citywide 5-Year Crashes 5
Maximum Points Available =35
Equity 15 30
Disadvantaged
Communities
Project Location is in or Adjacent to an HDC, APP, or is a Systemic Countermeasure 5
Project Location is not in or Adjacent to an HDC, APP, or is a Systemic Countermeasure 0
Transportation
Stress
Project Location is Above 90th Percentile for Traffic Proximity and Volume, and Above 65th Percentile for Low Income or is a Systemic
Countermeasure 10
Project Location is Above 90th Percentile for Traffic Proximity and Volume, or Above 65th Percentile for Low Income 5
Project Location is Not Above 90th Percentile for Traffic Proximity and Volume, or Above 65th percentile for Low Income 0
Disproportion
ate Impact
Applicable Emphasis Area(s) Experiences Higher Fatal and Serious Injury Rate in Local Disadvantaged Communities 5
Applicable Emphasis Area(s) Does Not Experience Higher Fatal and Serious Injury Rate in Local Disadvantaged Communities 0
Vulnerable
Road Users
Project is Applicable to Pedestrians and/or Bicyclists 5
Project is Not Applicable to Pedestrians and/or Bicyclists 0
Accessibility Project Eliminates a Barrier or Gap in Connectivity or Improves Transit Access 5
Project Does Not Eliminate a Barrier or Gap in Connectivity or Improve Transit Access 0
Maximum Points Available =30
Benefit
to Cost 20 15
Planning-Level
Benefit to Cost
Ratio
Planning-Level Benefit to Cost Ratio is 2.0 or Greater 15
Planning-Level Benefit to Cost Ratio is 1.0 or Greater 10
Planning-Level Benefit to Cost Ratio is Less Than 1.0 5
Maximum Points Available =15 17
Tentative Adoption Schedule
August 14 - Planning Commission Briefing
August 27 - City Council Briefing
→August 28 - Post Plan for Public Comment
→August 29 - Transportation, Parking, and Pedestrian Committee (TPPC) Briefing
→September 9 - Active Transportation Advisory Committee Briefing
→September 11 - Planning Commission Agenda Item for Adoption into Comp Plan
→Public Hearing during Planning Commission Adoption
→September 17 - City Council Public Hearing
→October 1 - City Council Adoption
18
Questions?
19